The Criminal Justice System Essay examples -- Restorative Justice, Me

The criminal justice constitution views any crime as a crime committed against the severalise and places much emphasis on retribution and paying back to the community, through time, fines or community work. Historically punishment has been a very public affair, which was erstwhile a key aspect of the punishment process, through the use of the stocks, dunking chair, pillory, and hangmans noose, although in todays society punishment has become a consider more private (Newburn, 2007). However it has been argued that although the debt against the state has been paid, the victim of the crime has been left with no legal input to seek adequate retribution from the offender, leaving the victim perhaps feeling unsatisfied with the criminal justice process.Furthermore can chunk social control institutions such as the criminal justice system and the government provide the best aspect of producing conformity and law abiding behaviour? Hirschis (1969) social control theory is concerned wit h what effect formal institutions have on conformity in individuals and in particular, how law abiding behaviour is produced due to these institutions (Walklate, 2005). However Wilson (2007) argues that formal methods of social control such as the criminal justice system are merely there to control and segregate delinquents and offenders who have not had adequate socialisation, which is where social mores are learnt and when conformity is produced, and that an secondary form of social control such as restorative justice might produce more effective results. The concept of restorative justice was severely shaped by the work of John Braithwaite (1989) who in turn was inspired by indigenous practices in New Zealand and Australia, whereby the significance of family value... ...apabilities to deal with this which is not the baptistery so much nowadays as Tony Marshall (1999) argues. There are criticisms over procedures, loss of rights such as an independent and impartial forum as wel l as the principle of proportionality in sentencing. There is also an unrealistic expectation that restorative justice can produce major changes in deviant behaviour, as there is not enough evidence to support this claim (Cunneen, 2007). Levrant et al (1999) on the other hand suggests that restorative justice tranquillise remains unproven in its effectiveness to stop reoffending and argues that its appeal lies in its apparent morality and humanistic sentiments rather than its empirical effectiveness. He continues to argue that it allows batch to feel better within themselves through having the moral high ground rather than focusing on providing justice to the offender.